Popsicle sticks. Yes. I can buy packs of them (tongue depressors too) at the "Chemistry Supply Store" on the MSU Campus. Good idea.
My paddle tails are all still quite ugly so far. I'm just trying to zero in on what works best, vis a vis a good balance between "paddles vigorously" and "still castable."
Once I get the global techniques landscape under control I'll work on beautiful. Graceful. Slick (as bug snot?).
I really do believe flies with action are a big deal. Fun to work with too.
Below is one of many reasons to fish with fly rod wigglers and/or paddle tails. I caught this 25" inch Channel Cat on a 6wt fly rod in chocolate brown water. On a wiggler, casting from a slowly moving drift boat.
If the boat hadn't been following this fish I never would have caught it. This fish took line off the reel on and off for a good 15 minutes. I'd pump him in and reel reel reel and then he'd run off another 30 feet of line again. Channel Cats fight forever.
Here's another photo of the same fish. A few hours later.
This was a three day float on a remote prairie river. Patrick (my fishing/hunting/camping buddy) filleted the fish and rolled it in an egg batter made with crushed potato chips. I baked the potatoes in tin foil. In a pot with a lid, on a small propane camp stove.
The rancher whose land we were camping on came by to check us out. He was the only human we saw in three days of floating the river. In trout water we'd have been playing bumper boats with fishing guides all day long. The whole way.
We promised the rancher we'd leave no sign of camping behind us. We didn't even make a fire. Propane camp stove and two tents (Patrick snores). Lots of coffee and sourdough pancakes in the morning.