hard to find palming reels with some heft to them, most palmers are modern and lightweight.
I love the JW Young 15-series as already mentioned in the thread..
Pflueger RC are perfectly good reels but not quite classics, fully functional though.
In non-palming, depending on what you fish for, an automatic reel will be nice and heavy.. I find they work great for most warmwater except big carp, and smaller trout. This is a Shakespeare, also have a Perrine free-stripping auto in the pile, need to clean it up and try it out..
Also partial to the Farlows Python, Cobra and Serpent click-pawls.
viewtopic.php?f=4&t=14356and
viewtopic.php?f=2&t=62897'The Gordon' reel by Sharpes is another classic-looking click-pawl with some heft to it in the wide-frame version, and these are fairly easily found.
viewtopic.php?f=4&t=5795#p36984