jgestar wrote:
G-ManBart wrote:
I spotted this rod at a small auction and was considering bidding on it.
Oops. I didn't notice that earlier. In general I prefer if we don't discuss rods until the auction is over.
First off, sellers have signed up just to woof about us bad mouthing their valuable goods (not that they didn't deserve it...). Still, talking up an auction (or the opposite) could be considered price manipulation. Auction prices should be determined by the people bidding, not the peanut gallery.
Second, as my father-in-law used to say to anyone late to dinner, "We waited for you, just like one dog waits for another". In other words, highlighting an auction before it is over is a good way to get outbid. At least a couple of posters have expressed their interest in finding an example of this rod for themselves. So be warned, there are no 'dibs' at online auctions.
Finally, if the rod photos shown were taken by the seller, we don't have the right to display them without the seller's permission. The seller owns the copyright to the photos, even if the rod is sold. I try to defend the copyrights of forum members when I see them misused. I don't think we should misuse the copyrights of others.
Tom
Sorry, my mistake. My intent was just ID, not value, condition, etc so I wasn't thinking along those lines, but I totally get what you're saying.
I was going off the sticky about eBay and it mentioned other auctions, etc and thought it was okay...the section below is what I thought said it was okay but I can see how I read it wrong:
"If someone requests a particular rod on the Wanted forum, posting a link to an eBay auction in that thread would be appropriate (or a link to any other website).
It would also be appropriate to link to an auction/commercial site if the particular rod or reel is the subject of a discussion thread."
I can edit and remove the pictures if you think it's appropriate.