Approximate values are just that - approximate. Without a particular rod in hand, or at the very least a large set of good photos, the condition really can't be determined. That can only be judged from a good visual inspection. The best option is to do your homework by watching eBay auctions and other online sales. After a time you will have a 'close enough' ability to judge value. A few things that go into the estimate; condition, completeness of the kit, rarity, time of year, condition, design and utility as a fishing rod, collector interest, potential for unseen damage, luck, access to motivated buyers, and, of course, condition.
That said, we have two unseen Fenwicks. Assuming the FF70 is in 'great' condition it could sell for $100-175 or more. This is a well loved early Fenwick. They are nice casting rods that few people sell because they don't like them. While the FF70 isn't rare, it isn't seen as often as the heavier rods. If the original rod bag and tube are present, add $25-40 (no bag or tube, subtract $25-50). Selling in late spring as the water levels drop and stream side foliage gets thicker (meaning shorter rods fish better on some streams) add $25-50 (selling in September-November, subtract 30%). Selling at a fishing show with dozens of well stocked competitors? subtract 25-40%. Selling on eBay in February-March with a very good set of photos and a bombproof shipping method, add 15-40%. Selling on Etsy or CraigsList? good luck.
The FF756 with a short tip is a different story. A short tip destroys value, competent repair or not. Value maybe $20-30. A broken tip is a very visible sign the rod was abused at least once, so there is a potential for other issues too. The FF756 may have been the most sold Fenwick fly rod ever, but they weren't the most loved on the market. Thus they are readily available in very good shape. Rarity and collector interest won't increase the value. Without the snapped tip? $75-120 is a likely price range.
Tom
|