Quote:
Ah, so you're alluding to something like a Commando shooting head, right? that's what it sounds like (to me). In which case, sure, they're great for beginners to learn sustained anchor casting techniques, but their utility isn't the same as a standard WFF line. It's all about sustained anchor casting (often employed with a two hander, but exceptionally fun with a single hander as well). All of that said, if by making it easier to employ such a technique for smaller trout sized fish for people who love that style of casting, then I guess you could call it a crutch. But, it takes a far higher level than "beginner" to become really proficient at it....hence my blanket statement comment.
No the specific experience I was recalling was of a line I found on a reel I bought off the Bay (a really nice Marquis 5WT) which I bought from the UK. No idea what the brand is.
The reel and the line looked unused and the line was spooled with insufficient backing and not properly set up so it is 95% sure that this line was sold to a beginner......who probably gave up fly fishing. But that's speculation.
I understand that you actually have a suitable application for this style of line. I myself bought a few Barrio SLX lines with a specific river in mind with high banks where I thought a spey cast and swing through the run might be a fun (if not particularly productive) technique. This is a river in Bavaria with big fish that take big flies where a 6wt is in order.
What I can tell you is that there are few situations here or in the UK where swinging small flies in trout streams (4WT) on the end of a shooting head is going to be an effective technique. You need a DT or longer WF so that you can mend and maintain a more or less dead drift if you are fishing small soft hackles that imitate emergers or nymphs. You might at some point want to retard downstream progress to simulate emergence but you don't want to quickly swim the flies towards the bank as happens on a classic swing at the end of a shooting head unless they are imitating minnows and/or inducing an aggressive response.
Aggressive line for aggressive fish