If those are the only choice I'd pick the Spartan, that does not mean you should though. I would advise you try both on, so to speak, before you buy; is there a dealer near you? Cabela's? A fly-tying class? anywhere that you could sit next to and put your hands on them. or maybe another as well.
"What would be the difference?" about $110 depending on source. This discussion explains the major differences are size of knobs, levers and such;
http://hmhvises.com/board/index.php?topic=115.0largely a matter of tyer comfort, the jaws interchange, so either has the capability of large and small hooks.
I probably should not even offer advise on this anyhow, since I am still tying on the Thompson A from long ago. I saw an as new in the box A on the auction a while back and wish now I had bought it for a grand kid.