I've been sorting through my rods, trying to select some rods to sell and I realized I have quite a few 7' 6" Phillipsons. I thought I would post a mini comparison between the one's I've had out in the back yard recently. It is based on casting over a brief period of time when no fishing was involved, so take it for what it is.
R76 (Royal, Eponite, 50's era tobacco glass) This is a great rod, and compares well against the other classic 50's era rods. The looks are distinctive with the red and green wraps over tobacco glass. I consider this a good 6 or 7wt rod. It will cast either, but this rod is very nice when it loads a bit deeper so I would say it is a better 7wt rod. It does have a bit of tip bounce.
Johnson Profile 400 (4F76). This is another Eponite blank, but painted a mustard yellow. It is also a 6/7 wt rod. This rod is a wonderful fast action 6wt rod, it casts as good as any 7'6" graphite rod, but it is heavier. I noticed no tip bounce that the R76 had. With a 7wt line on it, this rod loads a bit deeper, but it still isn't a slow rod. If you look at the old post:
viewtopic.php?f=3&t=52258&p=232504 you will see other opinions that this rod might want a bit heavier line than the 6wt it's rated at.
G-MF76 (Green wraps on the Master, yellow, Scotchply with the metal ferrule). This rod is a fun rod to cast with both a 6wt and 7wt line. It loads deeper than the Profile 400 and is lighter, but it is slower and doesn't throw as tight a loop, but is a better roll cast and is more "fiberglassy" with a deeper bend. It seems like it should throw a lighter line, but it really isn't a 5wt.
DF76 (Deluxe, red blank with metal ferrule). This rod looks like the Master with a different paint job, but is a different taper. It is even slower and might cast a 5wt line (I didn't try it). If you slow down, it is fun with the 6wt line. It is even more limber than the master, and required a bit more slowing down.
The fickle nature of fiberglass is one that makes me hesitate to choose a favorite. As far as fishing tools go, the Johnson Profile 400 would be my choice if I wanted to fish a wide variety of locations/techniques. (and the R76 was a close second). However the Scotchply blanks are lighter and more fun to cast.
Today it was the G-MF76 that just put a smile on my face. Though I'm sure that it would be a different rod on a different day.
I didn't have a Glass (sleeved) ferrule 7' 6" or a spigot ferruled 3-m rod or a Epoxite to compare.
Does anyone else have a favorite Phillipson in this size?
[Edit: changed the references to Epoxite to scotchply per the update below.]